|
|
||||||||
Musculoskeletal Imaging |
1 From the Department of Radiology, School of Medicine, University of California, San Diego Medical Center, and the Department of Osteoradiology (114), Veterans Affairs Medical Center, 3350 La Jolla Village Dr, San Diego, CA 92161. Received april 24, 1998; revision requested June 29; revision received December 16; accepted January 7, 1999. Address reprint requests to D.R.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective study of MR images and conventional radiographs was performed in 10 patients with posteromedial tibial plateau injuries, including avulsion fractures of the semimembranous tendon insertion site. Associated abnormalities were analyzed, including ACL tears, medial meniscal tears, and other lateral femorotibial compartment injuries. Findings from the clinical history and physical examination were correlated with radiographic and MR imaging findings. Nine patients had arthroscopically or surgically documented ACL tears.
RESULTS: All 10 patients had ACL tears at MR imaging. Five patients had posteromedial tibial plateau fractures: Four had avulsion fractures of the tendon insertion site, and one had a fracture lateral to the site. Five patients had posteromedial tibial plateau bruises: Two had bruises at the tendon insertion site. Five patients had tears of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus. Two patients had posterior meniscocapsular separations. Three patients showed evidence of the O'Donoghue triad. Six patients had bruises of the lateral tibial plateau and of the lateral femoral condyle.
CONCLUSION: There appears to be an association between posteromedial tibial plateau injuries and ACL tears. Posteromedial tibial plateau injuries may be predictive of ACL status.
Index terms: Knee, fractures, 454.121411, 454.121413, 454.121415, 454.41, 454.4191 Knee, injuries, 454.41, 454.4191, 454.4857 Knee, ligaments, menisci, and cartilage, 454.4857 Knee, MR, 454.121411, 454.121413, 454.121415
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Little attention has been paid to injuries of the posteromedial tibial plateau. A few investigators (4,11,15) briefly mentioned the presence of osseous abnormalities of the posteromedial tibial plateau when they studied the association of the posterolateral femorotibial compartment and ACL injuries. Two cases of avulsion fracture of the semimembranous tendon insertion site in the posteromedial tibial plateau were found to be associated with ACL tears (16), and, subsequently, one additional case together with findings of a cadaveric study were reported (17). The prevalence and mechanism of these injuries have been debated. The frequency of association of ACL tears to posteromedial tibial plateau injuries in the vicinity of the semimembranous tendon insertion, however, has not been emphasized. The purposes of this study were to retrospectively investigate posteromedial tibial plateau injuries of or about the semimembranous tendon insertion site, as seen on MR images, and to evaluate their association with ACL tears.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MR imaging was performed by using several 1.5-T magnets (Signa, GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, Wis; Vision, Siemens Medical Systems, Iselin, NJ) with a dedicated extremity coil. Patients were imaged in the conventional supine position. With the four Signa magnets, although pulse sequences varied, in general, the following protocols were used: parasagittal spin-echo (SE) intermediate-weighted (2,300/30 [repetition time msec/echo time msec]), SE T2-weighted (2,300/80), and short inversion time inversion-recovery (3,666/17/150 [repetition time msec/echo time msec/inversion time msec]) sequences; coronal fast SE T1-weighted (500755/1320) and fast SE intermediate-weighted fat-saturated (3,0003,950/1820) sequences; and axial fast SE intermediate-weighted fat-saturated (3,0003,950/1720) sequences or fast SE T2-weighted fat-saturated (3,000/84) sequences.
With the Vision magnet, the following pulse sequences were used: parasagittal fast SE intermediate-weighted (2,500/16), fast SE T2-weighted (2,500/98), short inversion time inversion-recovery (5,300/30/150) sequences; coronal SE T1-weighted (600/14) and fast SE intermediate-weighted fat-saturated (3,000/15) sequences; and axial three-dimensional double-echo steady state sequence (DESS, Siemens Medical Systems; 26/9, 40° flip angle).
The matrix was 256 x 192. Depending on the sequence used, the field of view was either 14 x 14 cm or 15 x 15 cm, and the number of signals acquired was either one or two.
Two authors (K.K.C., D.R.), by using the consensus, analyzed the MR images and classified them by the type of injury to the posteromedial tibial plateau: (a) avulsion fracture of the semimembranous tendon insertion site in the medial tibial plateau, (b) fracture of the medial tibial plateau without avulsion of this insertion site, and (c) bone bruise involving the posteromedial tibial plateau. Other recorded MR findings included the following: presence of an ACL tear, based on lack of the normal low-signal-intensity band of the ACL in all three planes; meniscal tear, defined by the presence of high signal intensity extending to the surface of the meniscus; meniscocapsular separation, defined by abnormal high signal intensity separating the meniscus and the adjacent capsule; collateral ligament injury, defined by the presence of high signal intensity in or around the ligament and by disruption of the ligament; lateral tibial plateau fractures; and lateral femoral condylar bone bruises. When available, conventional radiographs of the knee and results of arthroscopy or surgery were reviewed.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Nine patients had arthroscopically or surgically documented ACL tears. Arthroscopy had been performed in seven patients. When noted in the arthroscopic reports, meniscal findings correlated with findings on MR images. The presence of meniscocapsular separations was not noted on the arthroscopic reports. Inspection of the posteromedial corner of the knee with regard to the semimembranous tendon was not accomplished. Six patients subsequently underwent surgical repair of the ACL, and one patient underwent repair of the medial collateral ligament with meniscectomy but without ACL repair. This last patient continued to have pain after the surgery and had progression of symptoms and signs related to the ACL tear, including a positive anterior drawer sign and a positive Lachman test result. Two patients were treated conservatively. Clinical information was unavailable in one patient.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Unlike posterolateral tibial plateau fractures, which are very often associated with avulsion fractures of the posterior cruciate ligament (18), the 7-shaped contour is not interrupted (Fig 1b). This 7-shaped line is formed by the posterior aspect of the intercondylar tibial cortex and by the posterior aspect of the tibial spine. When this line is interrupted, an avulsion fracture of the posterior cruciate ligament insertion site is suggested. At MR imaging, an avulsion fracture or a contusion of the posteromedial tibial plateau can be detected easily.
In several large series (4,11,15) of patients with internal derangements of the knee, the incidence of osseous abnormalities of the posteromedial tibial plateau varied from 0% to 40%, although the importance of the lesions was not addressed. Rosen et al (15) noted that among patients who had an ACL injury, 40% also had injuries to the posteromedial tibial plateau, and 5% had injuries to the medial femoral condyle. Speer et al (4) reported a 29% frequency of medial tibial plateau lesions and a 10% frequency of medial femoral condyle lesions in skiers with ACL tears. Kaplan et al (11) reported a 7% incidence of associated medial tibial plateau occult fracture without any medial femoral condylar injuries in patients with ACL injuries. Thus, the frequency of injuries in this portion of the tibia appears to be higher than once thought.
In our 10 patients, an injury to the posteromedial tibial plateau was always associated with an ACL tear. Vanek's (17) cadaveric study findings showed that the ACL was torn before the medial tibial plateau translated anteriorly, which led to a posteromedial tibial plateau fracture. Therefore, the presence of a fracture of the posteromedial tibial plateau appears to be predictive of an associated ACL tear.
The mechanism leading to this type of injury, however, is not clear. Yao and Lee (16) proposed that an avulsion fracture of the semimembranous tendon insertion site is related to external rotation and abduction of the lower leg when the knee is flexed, perhaps because the semimembranous muscle is both a flexor and an internal rotator of the tibia. However, in Vanek's (17) study, fracture of the semimembranous tendon insertion site or of the adjacent tibial plateau was created by applying a varus force to the knee held in 60°80° of flexion. This resulted in external rotation of the tibia and anterior subluxation of the medial tibial plateau (17), which produced an impaction injury of the medial tibial plateau.
However, our study findings showed that none of the patients had associated impaction injuries of the medial femoral condyle. Therefore, the posteromedial tibial plateau lesions apparently were not related to a compressive force. Instead of a varus force, we believe that a valgus force applied to the tibia most likely causes external rotation and, possibly, anterior subluxation of the tibia in a mechanism similar to the one that leads to a tear of the ACL (1). We suggest, further, that during this injury, as the ACL is torn, the knee subluxates anteriorly and rotates externally, which produces a torque on the posteromedial aspect of the knee. This may lead to an avulsion fracture or a contusion of the posteromedial tibial plateau.
The semimembranous muscle has a complex insertion site in the posterior aspect of the knee (16,19). The central tendon, which is seen at MR imaging as a low-signal-intensity structure, inserts on the infraglenoid tubercle of the posteromedial tibial plateau. In our study, the avulsion fractures occurred at the insertion site of this central tendon. In addition, the semimembranous tendon sends fibers to the posterior capsule, to the posterior horn of the medial meniscus, and to a portion of the capsule that is deep to the medial collateral ligament. Traction on these additional fibers may cause an associated tear of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus, a posterior capsular injury, a meniscocapsular separation, or a combination of these injuries. In all cases, there was no evidence of the semimembranous tendon tear or rupture. The exact reason for the avulsion fracture of the tibia rather than a semimembranous tendon injury presumably relates to the fact that the tendon itself is stronger than its insertion site.
Bone injuries in the lateral compartment are well-known ancillary signs of a tear of the ACL. In our study, six of 10 patients had concurrent contusions of the lateral femoral condyle and of the posterolateral tibial plateau. The fact that lateral compartment injuries were so closely associated with injury to the posteromedial tibial plateau leads us to suggest that when the ACL is torn, the resultant rotary instability causes both traction to be applied to the medial aspect of the knee and impaction of its lateral aspect. As a result, injuries occur to both the medial tibial plateau and the lateral femorotibial compartment.
There are some limitations to the study. All cases were selected from a teaching file, which probably led to a selection bias. Although our review suggests a definite relationship between posteromedial tibial plateau injury and ACL injury, we did not determine the specificity of the plateau injury with regard to the ACL injury. Furthermore, we did not study the frequency of injury in and around the semimembranous tendon insertion site in patients with ACL injury.
In addition, the small number of cases prevented statistical analysis. Most of the cases did not have conventional radiographic correlation. Furthermore, MR imaging protocols were not uniform. Small, nondisplaced fractures may be missed on MR images and interpreted as only bone marrow edema. Some of these osseous lesions at the posteromedial aspect of the tibia may also be caused by impaction injuries rather than by avulsion injuries. Owing to the retrospective nature of the study, arthroscopic data were limited, particularly with regard to the presence of meniscocapsular separation or small fractures in the posteromedial corner of the knee.
In summary, our data, derived from an analysis of information from 10 patients, indicate that a fracture of the posteromedial tibial plateau is predictive of an associated ACL tear, although the mechanism leading to this type of bone injury is not clear.
| Footnotes |
|---|
3 Current address: Department of Radiology, Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center, Lebanon, NH. ![]()
4 Current address: Department of Radiological Sciences, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, Calif. ![]()
Abbreviations: ACL = anterior cruciate ligament SE = spin echo
Author contributions: Guarantors of integrity of entire study, K.K.C., D.R.; study concepts and design, K.K.C., D.R.; literature research, K.K.C.; clinical studies, D.G., K.K.C., D.R., L.L.S.; data acquisition, K.K.C., L.L.S., D.G.; data analysis, K.K.C., D.R.; manuscript preparation, K.K.C.; manuscript editing, D.R.; manuscript review, K.K.C., D.R.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. S. Prince, T. Laor, and J. A. Bean MRI of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries and Associated Findings in the Pediatric Knee: Changes with Skeletal Maturation Am. J. Roentgenol., September 1, 2005; 185(3): 756 - 762. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. G. Pao The Lateral Femoral Notch Sign Radiology, June 1, 2001; 219(3): 800 - 801. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. T. Bencardino, Z. S. Rosenberg, R. R. Brown, A. Hassankhani, E. S. Lustrin, and J. Beltran Traumatic Musculotendinous Injuries of the Knee: Diagnosis with MR Imaging RadioGraphics, October 1, 2000; 20(90001): 103S - 120. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
C. W. Hayes, M. K. Brigido, D. A. Jamadar, and T. Propeck Mechanism-based Pattern Approach to Classification of Complex Injuries of the Knee Depicted at MR Imaging RadioGraphics, October 1, 2000; 20(90001): 121S - 134. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| RADIOLOGY | RADIOGRAPHICS | RSNA JOURNALS ONLINE |