|
|
||||||||
Vascular and Interventional Radiology |
1 From the Department of Radiology, Tulane University School of Medicine, 1430 Tulane Ave, New Orleans, LA 70112 (E.K.L.); the Department of Radiology, State University of New York Health Science, Brooklyn (R.G.); the Department of Radiology, Louisiana State University School of Medicine, New Orleans (V.C.S., S.A.); and the Department of Radiology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC (J.R.). Received February 18, 1999; revision requested April 5; final revision received September 28; accepted October 4. Address correspondence to E.K.L.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The authors evaluated 100 patients (63 men, 37 women; age range, 2778 years) with pleural (n = 23) or deep (n = 77) lesions. Thirty-eight patients had emphysema. Patients were randomly assigned to one of two groups: those in whom the biopsy track was sealed with autologous blood clot (n = 50) and those who did not receive autologous blood clot (n = 50). Biopsy was performed with computed tomographic (CT) guidance and a 19-gauge coaxial system. The autologous blood clot, which ranged from 0.5 to 4.5 mL, was injected while the sheath was being withdrawn.
RESULTS: Pneumothorax developed in four of the 23 patients (17%) with pleural lesions and 19 of the 77 patients (24%) with deep lesions. Pneumothorax occurred in four of the 45 patients (9%) who had deep lesions and received autologous blood clot and in 15 of the 32 patients (47%) who had deep lesions and did not receive autologous blood clot (P < .001). In patients with emphysema, pneumothorax occurred in three of the 20 patients (15%) who received autologous blood clot and 10 of the 14 (71%) who did not (P < .001). There were seven large pneumothoraces necessitating treatment; all occurred in patients who did not receive autologous blood clot.
CONCLUSION: Plugging of biopsy tracks with ABCS, particularly after biopsy of deep lung lesions, significantly reduced the frequency of pneumothoraxparticularly of large pneumothoracesand, therefore, the need for treatment and the attendant cost.
Index terms: Lung, biopsy, 60.126 Lung, CT, 60.12115 Pneumothorax, 60.732
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The location of the lesion and imaging characteristics were known in all patients from previously obtained computed tomographic (CT) scans. CT was performed with 10-, 8-, 5-, and 4-mm-thick sections with fourth-generation scanners (CGR, Baltimore, Md; GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, Wis; and Siemens Medical Systems, Iselin, NJ). A spiral technique was used in about 38% of patients.
The location of the lesion was transferred to a skin marker indicating the shortest skin-to-lesion distance. Twenty-three lesions were pleural (parenchymal lesions had direct contact with the pleural surface); of these, six were also adjacent to the diaphragm. Seventy-seven lesions were deep (lesions were separated from the pleura by aerated lung). The lesions were located 1.08.0 cm (mean, 3.6 cm) from the pleural surface. The nodules ranged in diameter from 0.8 to 5.2 cm (mean, 2.2 cm). Cavitation was present in three of the 100 lesions (3%).
In the patients treated with ABCS, a mean of 1.72 needle passes were made per lesion; a mean of 1.80 needle passes per lesion were made in patients who did not receive autologous blood clot. There was no statistically significant difference in the ages or lesion sizes of patients treated without ABCS (mean age, 48 years; mean lesion size, 2.4 cm) and with ABCS (mean age, 54 years; mean lesion size, 2.0 cm). Thirty-eight patients had emphysema (21 treated with ABCS; 17 treated without ABCS), which was classified as moderate in 32 patients and severe in six. Three of the patients with severe emphysema did not receive autologous blood clot.
After proper preparation and draping, a local anesthetic was instilled to the level of the parietal pleura. The 22-gauge needle was left in position and a CT scan was obtained to confirm the proper location in relation to the lesion. A coaxial 19-gauge needle system (Temno Coaxial, Bauer, Clearwater Fla; DCBS 100, Cook, Bloomington, Ind) was then advanced to the near margin of the lesion. Advancement of the coaxial needle was carried out after a small inspiration. This minimizes subsequent excursion of the coaxial sheath during breathing and reduces the risk of pleural tear. For deep lesions, a track was selected that allows a perpendicular puncture and avoids fissures, blebs, and large vessels. For pleural lesions, a tangential approach was used. Proper location was confirmed with CT, and one to four aspiration biopsies were performed with 2022-gauge needles (Chiba and Francene; Cook) (Fig 1a). The specimens were assessed with cytopathologic examination (n = 100), histopathologic examination (n = 86), and flow cytometry (n = 18).
|
|
After completion of the biopsy, supernatant serum and autologous blood clot were injected in 50 patients while the coaxial sheath was being withdrawn, placing the clot from the biopsy site to the visceral pleura (Fig 1b). In the other 50 patients, the coaxial sheath was withdrawn in one swift motion.
The ABCS was prepared by removing 4.08.0 mL of blood from an antecubital vein and allowing the blood to clot in the syringe. Then, 0.53.0 mL of clot and 0.51.5 mL of supernatant were injected at the level of the biopsied nodule, filling the entire track to the visceral pleura (Figs 1b, 2, 3b). The supernatant was primarily deployed at the level of biopsied nodule, the solid clot elements in the peripheral track, and at the point of exit from the visceral pleura.
|
|
|
Finally, a posteroanterior radiograph was obtained before discharge. If a small pneumothorax (5% or less) was present, the patient was either discharged or, if his or her condition was clinically unstable, observation was continued. In patients with a moderate pneumothorax (20%40%) and particularly in those with emphysema, a 6-F chest tube was introduced. Pneumothoraces of 5% or up to 20% were treated with aspiration through the coaxial sheath and observation for 4 hours. Only those patients with a large pneumothorax who failed to respond to the above measures underwent insertion of a chest tube with waterproof seal and suction.
The frequency of pneumothorax was analyzed according to the presence of emphysema, whether lesions were pleural or deep, and whether ABCS was used in the biopsy track. Statistical calculations were performed by using the
2 test. A P value less than .001 indicated a statistically significant difference.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
In the 77 patients with deep lesions, pneumothorax occurred in four of the 45 patients (9%) treated with ABCS and 15 of the 32 patients (47%) who did not receive autologous blood clot (P < .001). In patients with emphysema, pneumothoraces occurred in 10 of the 14 patients (71%) who did not receive autologous blood clot and three of the 20 patients (15%) who did (P < .001). Moreover, there was a statistically significant difference in the rate of resultant large pneumothoraces (none of the patients [0%] who received autologous blood clot vs seven of the 32 patients [22%] who did not receive autologous blood clot; P = .001). The need for treatment was influenced by the presence of emphysema and the magnitude of the pneumothorax (20). No patient without emphysema and with a small pneumothorax (5% or less) needed treatment, but three of the eight patients with emphysema and a small pneumothorax had to be treated with aspiration and placement of a Heimlich valve (Bard-Parker; Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ) (Table).
All seven patients with deep lesions and a large pneumothorax required chest tube placement; a Heimlich valve was placed in four of these seven patients. Three patients did not respond to this treatment and underwent prolonged treatment with insertion of a chest tube with a waterproof seal and intermittent suction.
Four patients with a chest tube with suction and waterproof seal and one patient with a chest tube and Heimlich valve, all of which were placed to treat refractory pneumothoraces, were hospitalized for 26 days (mean, 3.6 days).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
There is consensus that the frequency of pneumothorax increases sharply when biopsy needles are larger than 18 gauge (1522). Although a 22-gauge biopsy needle will generally produce an adequate sample, biopsy guns that can be used through an 18-gauge sheath may be useful for diagnosing lesions other than carcinomas (21).
The frequency of pneumothorax in patients treated with a blood clot seal at removal of the biopsy sheath varies widely despite seemingly similar techniques. Surprenant (23) reported a frequency of pneumothorax of 5.5%, Bourgouin et al (19) a rate of 28.8%, and Herman and Weisbrod (24) a rate of 45%. All of these investigators used a similar technique of placing the blood patch. A much lower frequency of resultant pneumothorax of about 12% was reported by Moore (21) when using liquid blood to occlude the last 2 cm of the biopsy track. Part of the success in that series, however, may be attributable to meticulous planning of the biopsy trajectory, thus avoiding complications of pneumothorax. The use of a compressed collagen foam plug to seal the pleural biopsy site has resulted in a rate of postbiopsy pneumothorax of 8% (vs 28% in a control group that did not receive a collagen foam plug) (25).
Our method of plugging the biopsy track with ABCS appears to significantly reduce the occurrence of pneumothorax, particularly of large pneumothoraces, thereby reducing the need for treatment and hospitalization. In deep lesions with 1.08.0-cm-long biopsy tracks, ABCS reduced the frequency of pneumothorax from 47% (15 of 32 patients) to 9% (four of 45 patients) (P < .001). Moreover, the four resultant pneumothoraces in patients with ABCS and deep lesions were small, and only one (in a patient with emphysema) necessitated treatment with a chest tube and Heimlich valve for 2 days. Conversely, in our 32 patients with deep lesions who did not receive autologous blood clot, seven of the 15 resultant pneumothoraces were large, necessitating treatment with chest tube and Heimlich valve in four and waterproof sealed suction drainage in three (Table). Three of these large pneumothoraces appeared 46 hours after biopsy, which is indicative of continued leakage. Two other patients with small pneumothoraces had to be treated with chest tube and Heimlich valve because of the presence of emphysema (Table).
Similar to the experience reported by Fish et al (11), our rate of complicating pneumothorax necessitating treatment in patients with deep lesions was considerably greater in patients with emphysema than in those without emphysema (six of 34 patients [18%] vs two of 43 patients [5%], respectively). The markedly reduced need for treatment of biopsy complications and hospitalization was primarily responsible for curtailing cost. As judged by limited follow-up of nine patients who underwent CT a mean of 57 days after biopsy (162 weeks), ABCS did not induce untoward reactions or late sequela. Although the need for ABCS in patients with pleural lesions may be reduced because the biopsy track traverses an area of pleural fixation, a pneumothorax can result if one is dealing with a visceral pleural lesion and the lung retracts. In such patients, the use of an ABCS may be advantageous (Fig 3).
The seemingly lower rate of pneumothoraces in our seriesparticularly of large pneumothoracescompared with that reported in other series may be attributable to a number of modifications in technique (19,2224). Meticulous planning of the trajectory of the proposed biopsy track to avoid fissures, blebs, large vessels and, if possible, to follow scars that extend to the pleural surface and the use of the perpendicular entry will in themselves reduce the risk of pneumothorax, as has also been shown by other investigators (21). Immediate positioning of the affected side downward will maximize the effect of the ABCS. Our technique of injecting supernatant at the point of entry of the biopsy track into the lesion and clot at the visceral pleural exit site of the track appears to ensure a better seal. Moreover, because of the dependent position, the supernatant will settle toward the visceral pleural entry site of the track and afford further seal. Last, adherence to a 4-hour rest period bridges the most crucial postoperative period during which pneumothoraces develop.
On the basis of our experience, the use of ABCS placed through the coaxial sheath is strongly recommended when performing biopsy of deep lesions because it significantly reduces the frequency of pneumothorax and the subsequent need for chest tube placement and hospitalization.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Author contributions: Guarantor of integrity of entire study, E.K.L.; study concepts and design, E.K.L.; definition of intellectual content, E.K.L.; literature research, E.K.L., R.G.; clinical studies, E.K.L., V.C.S., J.R., S.A.; data acquisition, V.C.S., J.R., S.A.; data analysis, E.K.L., R.G.; statistical analysis, R.G.; manuscript preparation, R.G.; manuscript editing and review, E.K.L.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
H. T. Winer-Muram The solitary pulmonary nodule. Radiology, April 1, 2006; 239(1): 34 - 49. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A Manhire, M Charig, C Clelland, F Gleeson, R Miller, H Moss, K Pointon, C Richardson, and E Sawicka Guidelines for radiologically guided lung biopsy Thorax, November 1, 2003; 58(11): 920 - 936. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. B. Haramati and G. Aviram What Constitutes Effective Management of Pneumothorax After CT-Guided Needle Biopsy of the Lung? Chest, April 1, 2002; 121(4): 1013 - 1015. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. E. Silberzweig, C. Hilfer, and E. K. Lang Embolization of an Autologous Clot Dr Lang responds: Radiology, May 1, 2001; 219(2): 574 - 574. [Full Text] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| RADIOLOGY | RADIOGRAPHICS | RSNA JOURNALS ONLINE |