|
|
||||||||
Pediatric Imaging |
1 From the Unit of Diagnostic and Therapeutic Neuroradiology, Azienda Ospedaliera Senese, and the InterDepartmental Center of Magnetic Resonance (P. Galluzzi, C.V., A.C., I.M.V., S.B., P. Gennari, L.M., G.F.), the Department of Pediatric Ophthalmology (A.M.B.), and the Center for Intraocular Tumors (T.H.), University of Siena, Policlinico "Le Scotte," Viale Mario Bracci 1, 53100 Siena, Italy. From the 2000 RSNA scientific assembly. Received November 27, 2000; revision requested January 4, 2001; revision received March 15; accepted April 6. Address correspondence to P. Galluzzi (e-mail: neurorad@ao-siena.toscana.it).
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ocular globe volume was assessed in 13 children (11 boys, two girls; age range, 0.614 years; mean age, 4.1 years) with Coats disease and in 18 (eight boys, 10 girls; age range, 0.512 years; mean age, 3.6 years) with unilateral retinoblastoma. Orbital computed tomographic scans were available for all children; magnetic resonance images were available for 11 childrenseven with Coats disease and four with retinoblastoma. For volume estimation, anteroposterior and equatorial diameters of ocular globes were measured. Statistical analysis was conducted with univariate and multivariate methods.
RESULTS: In children with Coats disease, the mean volume of the affected globe was 4,877.03 mm3 (range, 2,951.476,284.70 mm3) and that of the normal globe, 6,018.00 mm3 (range, 4,062.327,509.26 mm3). In children with retinoblastoma, the mean volume of the affected globe was 4,557.06 mm3 (range, 1,612.017,463.00 mm3) and that of the normal globe, 4,402.11 mm3 (range, 1,360.46 7,463.00 mm3). The Coats disease population had a significantly smaller volume of the affected globe (z = -3.1009; P = .002); the retinoblastoma population did not have a statistically significant trend toward a bigger affected globe volume (z = -1.7064; P = .088). The difference between the affected globe volume and the normal globe volume in children with Coats disease was the only significant independent variable (P = .005).
CONCLUSION: A significantly smaller volume of the affected globe is an additional feature of Coats disease.
Index terms: Eye, abnormalities, 2245.372, 2245.69, 2245.892 Eye, CT, 224.1211 Eye, diseases, 2245.69 Eye, MR, 224.121411, 224.12143 Eye, neoplasms, 2245.372 Retina, 2245.372, 2245.69, 2245.892
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The diagnosis is generally made by means of indirect ophthalmoscopy, supplemented with A- and B-mode ultrasonography (US), and/or intravenous fluorescein angiography in selected patients (8,11,13). The main problem is to differentiate advanced Coats disease from retinoblastoma because both diseases may present with nonrhegmatogenous retinal detachment, telangiectases, and subretinal collections (6,1620). The differential diagnosis depends on the age at presentation, including an extensive list of primary and secondary, benign and malignant retinal detachmentrelated lesions (Table 1).
|
Observations in our clinical practice and a review of some published CT and/or MR images (22,28) led us to note that the volume of the affected globe (AG) in patients with Coats disease may be smaller than the volume of the contralateral unaffected eye. This finding has been mentioned in a prior report (23). The purpose of our study was to determine whether a statistically significant smaller volume of the AG, compared with that of the normal globe, may be an additional feature of Coats disease.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Clinical data were collected from inpatient and outpatient medical records at our institution and included sex, age, affected eye, stage of the disease at presentation, resulting from indirect ophthalmoscopy supplemented with intravenous fluorescein angiography and/or US in selected cases, surgery, and histologic examination, if performed. At our institution, institutional review board approval and informed consent are not required for retrospective review of medical records.
At the time of presentation, of the 13 children with Coats disease, seven underwent nonenhanced and contrast materialenhanced CT of the orbits, one underwent nonenhanced MR imaging, five underwent nonenhanced CT and nonenhanced and gadolinium-enhanced MR imaging, and one underwent nonenhanced and gadolinium-enhanced MR imaging. Of the 18 children with retinoblastoma, 14 underwent nonenhanced and contrast-enhanced CT of the orbits, and four underwent nonenhanced CT and nonenhanced and gadolinium-enhanced MR imaging. In all cases, parents had given informed consent for these diagnostic imaging examinations.
In the 13 children with Coats disease, clinical staging was based on the following classification system (3): stage 1, evidence of focal exudates; stage 2, massive intraretinal exudation; stage 3, partial exudative retinal detachment; stage 4, total retinal detachment; and stage 5, complications (rubeosis iridis, neovascular glaucoma, cataract[s], uveitis, or phthisis bulbi) secondary to chronic retinal detachment at indirect ophthalmoscopy. Clinical follow-up ranged from 1 to 11 years.
Serial 1.53-mm-thick transverse CT sections were available for this study, as well as serial nonenhanced T1-weighted spin-echo, fast and turbo T2-weighted spin-echo, and transverse gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted spin-echo 3-mm-thick sections obtained at MR imaging with 0.5-T and 1.5-T systems (Gyroscan ACSNT 5 and 15; Philips Medical Systems, Best, the Netherlands) by using surface and/or head coils.
One neuroradiologist (P. Galluzzi), blinded to the clinical diagnosis, evaluated the CT scans for intraocular attenuation, compared with the normal contralateral vitreous, the presence of intraocular calcifications and/or mass, and the pattern of contrast enhancement and evaluated the MR images for the signal intensity of intraocular lesions and/or subretinal collections, compared with the unaffected vitreous, and the pattern of gadolinium enhancement. In addition, at the CT and MR monitors, he measured anteroposterior and equatorial diameters of the 62 globes on sections showing the largest transverse plane of the eyeball, which usually shows the maximum size of the lens (34).
The anteroposterior diameter was determined as the distance from the posterior corneal surface to the posterior wall of the choroid, including the anterior chamber depth, lens thickness, and vitreous length. The equatorial diameter was obtained at the maximum transverse width (34,35). These measurements were made on both CT sections and on T1-weighted, T2-weighted, and gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted transverse MR images (Figs 1, 2). The largest diameters were used to estimate the volume with the following formula: [(anteroposterior diameter + equatorial diameter/2)/2]3 · (4/3
). Microphthalmos was defined as an eye with a volume of at least 2 SDs below the mean for age-similar controls (36); comparison was made with published standards (34).
|
|
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
None of the eyes were microphthalmic. The mean volume of the AG was 4,877.03 mm3 (range, 2,951.476,284.70 mm3; SD, 793.50) and of the contralateral normal globe, 6,018.00 mm3 (range, 4,062.327,509.26 mm3; SD, 1,005.60) (Fig 1). Four patients (patients 1013) underwent enucleation because of the development of painful glaucoma; histologic examination confirmed Coats disease.
The 18 children (eight boys and 10 girls) with unilateral retinoblastoma (Table 3) ranged in age from 6 months to 12 years (mean, 3.6 years). The right eye was affected in eight children and the left eye in 10. In all children, MR images and/or CT scans were typical for the tumor (22, 23,25,29,31). CT scans showed a mildly to moderately hyperattenuating intraocular mass with variable calcifications and moderate to marked enhancement after the administration of the contrast material, and MR images showed an intraocular lesion slightly to moderately hyperintense compared with the normal vitreous on T1-weighted images and darker on T2-weighted images, with moderate to marked enhancement after gadolinium administration. None of the eyes were microphthalmic. The mean volume of the AG was 4,557.06 mm3 (range, 1,612.017,463.00 mm3; SD, 1,981.00) and of the normal globe, 4,402.11 mm3 (range, 1,360.467,463.00 mm3; SD, 1,912.19) (Fig 2). All of these patients underwent enucleation. At histologic examination, 11 retinoblastomas were endophytic, one was exophytic, and six showed both endophytic and exophytic components.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
When ocular refractory media are opaque, clinical examination and US are limited. It may be difficult to differentiate advanced Coats disease from benign and malignant conditions with similar findings; however, the main problem remains the differentiation from retinoblastoma. Patients with retinoblastoma must not incur delay in receiving appropriate treatment (21). Prior intraocular surgery performed in patients with retinoblastoma may accelerate tumor seeding (8,21,37,38), and a secure diagnosis prevents unnecessary enucleation in cases with a benign disease (12,13). However, making the distinction between advanced Coats disease and retinoblastoma still remains a great challenge in clinical ophthalmology.
Several exceptions to the usual age at presentation have been reported (8,12) in both diseases. As many as 40% of the patients with advanced Coats disease present before the age of 2 years (8), such as occurred in six of the 13 patients in our study. Clinically, as many as 58% of the patients with Coats disease may undergo unnecessary enucleation (6,19), and as many as 16% of the patients with retinoblastoma may be misdiagnosed as having Coats disease (20). Notably, diffusely infiltrating retinoblastoma usually occurs outside the typical age group, shows atypical ophthalmoscopic features simulating inflammatory or hemorrhagic conditions, and often lacks calcification (10,22).
US does not improve the diagnosis in eyes with diffuse vitreous infiltration, poorly calcified masses, and complex interfaces. The analysis of aqueous humor for the levels of various substances is not as useful at present (8,39). Fine-needle subretinal aspiration biopsy is controversial because of the substantial risk of procedure-related tumor seeding (8,37). When the clinical diagnosis is uncertain, CT and/or MR imaging are required. Because intraocular calcifications in children younger than 3 years should be considered a manifestation of retinoblastoma, with the exceptions of children with microphthalmos and colobomatous cyst or choroidal osteoma and immunocompromised children with cytomegaloviral chorioretinitis (31), the main indication for CT is the search for intraocular calcifications (13,19,2224,28).
The imaging findings of Coats disease vary with the disease progression (11,22, 25,2729). In the early stages, imaging yields little or no information. In the advanced stages, the diagnosis is favored by partial or total retinal detachment, absence of an intraocular mass, homogeneously diffuse intraocular increased attenuation when compared with the vitreous of the unaffected eye, absence of intraocular calcifications on CT scans, and subretinal fluid hyperintense with all pulse sequences at MR imaging. After contrast administration, Coats disease may show enhancement along the leaves of the detached sensory retina and at the sites where retina inserts, while retinoblastoma enhances in a masslike fashion; these findings are obviously better shown on gadolinium-enhanced MR images with or without the fat-suppression technique (23,26,27,29).
Proton MR spectroscopy has been advocated for providing specific information by revealing a large lipid peak in the subretinal collection in Coats disease (30). Nowadays, patients with Coats disease generally undergo enucleation only when painful neovascular glaucoma occurs in a blind eye (13,29), such as occurred in four of the 13 patients in our study. However, and unfortunately, exceptions to the typical CT and MR features exist in both Coats disease and retinoblastoma, still resulting in unnecessary enucleation for equivocal or conflicting findings (10,16).
A retrolental enhancing gliotic mass simulating nodular retinoblastoma can occur in extreme cases of advanced Coats disease (33). The rare diffuse infiltrating retinoblastoma may not show nodularity with any imaging studies (22). On CT scans, as many as 5% of the retinoblastomas have no evidence of calcifications, especially diffuse infiltrating retinoblastomas (15,22). Furthermore, occasional reports of calcifications in Coats disease have been well documented (6,9,28,32). It has been reported (26,27) that MR images do not depict retinoblastomas with a thickness equal or less than 2 mm, even if a surface coil is used and gadolinium-enhanced fat-suppressed T1-weighted images are obtained. In the chronic stages of Coats disease, the MR signal intensity of subretinal fluid may become heterogeneous because of the combination of cholesterol crystals, hemorrhage, material positive for p-aminosalicylic acid, and scarring (8,11,14).
Because diagnosis is crucial if the necessary treatment is to be provided, specific diagnostic signs are of great value to clinicians, and specific imaging changes must be used in the best way. In our study, only the AGs of patients with Coats disease had a statistically significantly smaller volume when compared with those of the unaffected eyes. However, because of the limited sample, a larger more definitive study would be necessary to properly define the optimal cutoff of the differences between the AG volume and the normal globe volume. Although smaller size of the AG has been reported (23) in patients with Coats disease, to the best of our knowledge, this finding has never been described as statistically significant.
Haik (8) came to other conclusions by using CT measurements of the transverse length of both eyes in 19 patients with advanced Coats disease; 15 patients had a globe of normal size, two patients had slightly enlarged globes, and two patients had microphthalmic globes. This difference may be explained by the fact that, despite being slightly ellipsoidal, the ocular globe has been generally assumed to be spherical for volume estimation, because the error introduced is likely to be small (34,40). Furthermore, the globe size has generally been estimated with the measurement of only one of the globe diameters (8,34,41).
We evaluated the globe volume by measuring both the anteroposterior and equatorial diameters. The vertical diameter has been demonstrated to be equal to the anteroposterior diameter in emmetropic, hyperopic, and myopic eyes; thus, it is not necessary to measure the globe volume, annulling the need for coronal images (35). Three-dimensional high-spatial-resolution phased-array MR imaging may result in further improvement in eyeball volumetry (42).
The variability in the size of orbital structures from one person to another is large, but differences between the two sides in a normal population are small (43,44). Ocular globe volume is substantially influenced by age and sex (34, 45,46). A substantial rapid growth occurs in utero and until 18 months of age, followed by a phase of slower growth (45). Ocular globe almost doubles its volume from 3 cm3 at birth to approximately 6 cm3 at 24 months of age in both sexes. A 3-cm3 increment is noted from 2 to 1830 years of age. At 1830 years of age, the peak of 910 cm3 is reached. Reductions in ocular globe volume occur at an older age (34,45,46). The ocular globe volume is slightly larger in boys than in girls during the entire growth period; this difference remains relatively constant throughout the entire life (34,44). In our study, the relative larger size of the globes in the Coats disease population may be explained by the prevalence of boys and the higher mean age.
Ocular growth is a still incompletely understood complex process governed by a potentially large number of genes and environmental factors (47). Expansion of the vitreous body accounts for 60% of the eye prenatal growth and 90% of the postnatal growth (14,36,41). Vitreous growth in the vertical and equatorial directions proceeds equally until a certain choroidal-scleral thickness is reached. A uniform choroidal-scleral thinning is associated with a posterior vitreal expansion in the myopic eye, and choroidal-scleral thickening seems to control the posterior vitreal expansion in a relatively small hyperopic eye (35).
Some experimental studies in both animals and humans have demonstrated that the globe growth is influenced by the lens thickness in the same way as the growth of the whole orbit is influenced by the presence or absence of the eye (46). Other studies have shown that any tissue in the anterior or posterior eye segments, such as the lens, ciliary body, retina, and primary vitreous, influences the expansion of secondary vitreous by producing regulatory growth factors, thereby affecting ocular growth. Inadequate production of secondary vitreous that results in a microphthalmic eye is seen in some diseases such as coloboma, persistent hyperplastic primary vitreous, and retinal dysplasia (36,48).
In conclusion, our results allow us to postulate that the retinal vascular developmental abnormalities of Coats disease may disturb the release of growth factors that regulate the further development of secondary vitreous, thus resulting in the disturbance of the growth of the AG. We believe additional retrospective and prospective studies are needed to evaluate the significance of the smaller volume of the AG in Coats disease.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Author contributions: Guarantors of integrity of entire study, A.M.B., C.V.; study concepts and design, P. Galluzzi, T.H.; literature research, P. Gennari, A.C., G.F.; clinical studies, A.M.B., T.H., G.F., P. Galluzzi, A.C., L.M., I.M.V., P. Gennari; data acquisition, P. Galluzzi, A.C., S.B.; data analysis/interpretation, P. Galluzzi, I.M.V.; statistical analysis, P. Galluzzi, A.C.; manuscript preparation, P. Galluzzi, A.C.; manuscript definition of intellectual content, P. Galluzzi, A.C., T.H.; manuscript editing, A.C., P.G.; manuscript revision/review and final version approval, A.M.B., C.V.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. de Graaf, D. L. Knol, A. C. Moll, S. M. Imhof, A. Y. N. Schouten-van Meeteren, and J. A. Castelijns Eye Size in Retinoblastoma: MR Imaging Measurements in Normal and Affected Eyes Radiology, July 1, 2007; 244(1): 273 - 280. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. M. Chung, C. S. Specht, and J. W. Schroeder From the Archives of the AFIP: Pediatric Orbit Tumors and Tumorlike Lesions: Neuroepithelial Lesions of the Ocular Globe and Optic Nerve RadioGraphics, July 1, 2007; 27(4): 1159 - 1186. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Galluzzi, A. Cerase, T. Hadjistilianou, S. De Francesco, P. Toti, I. M. Vallone, G. Filosomi, L. Monti, S. Bracco, P. Gennari, et al. Retinoblastoma: Abnormal Gadolinium Enhancement of Anterior Segment of Eyes at MR Imaging with Clinical and Histopathologic Correlation Radiology, September 1, 2003; 228(3): 683 - 690. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| RADIOLOGY | RADIOGRAPHICS | RSNA JOURNALS ONLINE |